ND Critics Poll: Our Favorite Roots Music Albums of 2018

ND Critics Poll: Our Favorite Roots Music Albums of 2018

Around here, the Year-End Readers Poll (we call it YERP) is a highlight of the year. This time, 10,201 No Depression readers weighed in, creating a wide-ranging list of must-hear albums that came out in 2018. But we always like to give a special spotlight as well to the favorite albums of ND staffers, columnists, and reviewers who help sift through the pile of new music all year long.

Thing is, our list is all over the place. We all live in different places and hear different things and have different tastes, which is how we can bring you such a wide range of reviews and music-related thought in our columns. So we’ve highlighted a few that came up the most among our individual lists, along with an excerpt of the No Depression review of each one. From there, instead of a ranked list, we just made … a list. We hope you might find some new avenues for listening that maybe didn’t make the readers poll, and we look forward to turning you on to even more new finds in the new year. (Many of the albums on the list were reviewed by ND this year, so use that search field to find out more about each one!)

Contributing to this list are No Depression Managing Editor Hilary Saunders, Assistant Editor Stacy Chandler, Ad Manager Sonja Nelson, and Social Media and Marketing Manager Adam Kirr; columnists Chris Griffy, Amos Perrine, Ed Maxin, Henry Carrigan, and Isa Burke; and reviewers Jim Shahen, Michael Davis, Laura Stanley, Rachel Cholst, Mike Elliott, Bobby Moore, Cillea Houghton, Corbie Hill, and John Amen.

Common Ground

Kacey Musgraves – Golden Hour

Kacey Musgraves’ Golden Hour radiates with beauty and love; its glorious sheen imbues the world around it with a sparkling message to embrace wonder, revel in love, and to hold onto transitory moments of beauty that settle on or near you. — Henry Carrigan

Brandi Carlile – By the Way, I Forgive You

On her haunting and ethereally beautiful new album, By the Way, I Forgive You, Brandi Carlile delivers a stunningly powerful cycle of songs that illustrates the often-complex cycle of love and forgiveness. Carlile’s raw, emotional vocals go right to the heart of the matter, and the sparseness of many of the arrangements captures the aching desire arising out of ragged desolation and the longing for love for oneself and another. — HC

John Prine – The Tree of Forgiveness

Thirteen years after one of the more stellar mid-to-late career runs in popular music – the trifecta of 1991’s The Missing Years, 1995’s Lost Dogs and Mixed Blessings, and 2005’s Fair & Square – John Prine releases The Tree of Forgiveness, integrating his penchant for whimsicality, homespun wisdom, and heartrending insights, 10 songs delivered via alluring melodies and the award-winning singer-songwriter’s unmistakable voice. — John Amen

The War and Treaty – Healing Tide

Healing Tide does more than flesh out the themes first explored on Down to the River. With the addition of gritty Southern soul to the sonic palette, a full backing band, and excellent production from Buddy Miller, Healing Tide takes like five leaps forward musically. The result is one of the most jubilant, entertaining albums of the summer. — Jim Shahen

(The War and Treaty was No Depression’s Spotlight band in August. Read the story here.)

Sarah Shook & The Disarmers – Years

Shook is perfectly framed by guitarist Eric Peterson’s honky-tonk twang and Phil Sullivan's weeping pedal steel, a muscular framework that Shook swings from like a Bakersfield gymnast, a vocal blend of B-field's own Stacie Collins and the wild and wooly rockabilly tonsils of Wanda Jackson. — Grant Britt

I’m With Her – See You Around

The three artists co-wrote the songs (save for one Gillian Welch tune) and harmonize, sharing instrumental duties and taking turns on the occasional solo verse. A fully collaborative effort from start to finish, See You Around never sounds like a solo record from any of the women, and instead feels like the product of a new band. We get each of their sensibilities combined into something rich and rootsy. It comes as no surprise that they would already have admired each other’s work and felt it a natural fit to create something together. — Maeri Ferguson

The Brother Brothers – Some People I Know

From the outset, the Moss brothers are in the shadows of many legendary country and folk brothers — Everly, Louvin, and Stanley, just to name a few — but The Brother Brothers on their own merits make their debut album luminous. — Laura Stanley

(The Brother Brothers were the No Depression Spotlight band in October. Read the story here.)

The List (alphabetical)

Aaron Lee Tasjan – Karma for Cheap

Adrianne Lenker – abysskiss

Amanda Shires– To the Sunset

American Aquarium – Things Change

American Folk (Amber Rubarth & Joe Purdy) –  Original Motion Picture Soundtrack

Amigo – And Friends

Amy Ray – Holler

Ana Egge, White Tiger

Anderson East – Encore

Angelique Kidjo – Remain in Light

Anna & Elizabeth – The Invisible Comes to Us

Ashley McBryde – Girl Going Nowhere

Ashley Monroe – Sparrow

Austin Lucas – Immortal Americans

Barrence Whitfield & The Savages – Soul Flowers of Titan

Bettye LaVette – Things Have Changed

Blue Yonder – Rough and Ready Heart

Bottle Rockets – Bit Logic

boygenius – boygenius

Brothers Osborne – Port Saint Joe

Buck Meek – Buck Meek

Caroline Rose – Loner

Cat Power – Wanderer

Colter Wall – Songs of the Plains

Courtney Hartman & Taylor Ashton, Been On Your Side

Courtney Marie Andrews – May Your Kindness Remain

Cowboy Junkies – All That Reckoning

David Crosby – Here If You Listen

Dead Horses – My Mother the Moon

Dillon Carmichael – Hell on an Angel

Donna the Buffalo – Dance in the Streets

Doug Paisley – Starter Home

Erin Rae – Putting on Airs

Father John Misty – God’s Favorite Customer

Field Report – Summertime Songs

Frank Turner – Be More Kind

Gregory Alan Isakov – Evening Machines

Gretchen Peters – Dancing with the Beast

Haley Heynderickx – I Need To Start A Garden

Hawks and Doves – From a White Hotel

Hawktail – Unless

HC McEntire – LIONHEART

I See Hawks In L.A. – Live and Never Learn

Isla Craig – The Becoming

Jason Boland & The Stragglers – Hard Times are Relative

JD McPherson – Socks

Jeffrey Foucault – Blood Brothers

Jennifer Castle – Angels of Death

Jimmy LaFave – Peace Town

John Howie Jr. – Not Tonight

Joshua Hedley – Mr. Jukebox

Kaia Kater – Grenades

Kamasi Washington – Heaven and Earth

Kevin Welch – Dust Devil

Kieran Kane & Rayna Gellert – The Ledge

Leon Bridges – Good Thing

Lera Lynn – Plays Well With Others

Lindi Ortega – Liberty

Liz Cooper & the Stampede – Window Flowers

Loretta Lynn – Wouldn't it be Nice

Lori McKenna – The Tree

Lucy Dacus – Historian

Malcolm Holcombe – Come Hell or High Water

Mandy Barnett – Strange Conversation

Mary Gauthier – Rifles and Rosary Beads

Mariel Buckley – Driving in the Dark

Marisa Anderson – Cloud Comer

Marissa Nadler – For My Crimes

Mark Knopfler – Down the Road Wherever

Marlon Williams – Make Way For Love

Martha Scanlan – The River and The Light

Mickey Stephens & Poor Blue – Wasteground

Milk Carton Kids – All The Things That I Did and All The Things I Didn’t Do

Motel Mirrors – In the Meantime

Mountain Man – Magic Ship

Mumford and Sons – Delta

Neko Case – Hell–On

Nellie McKay – Sister Orchid

New Respects – Before the Sun Goes Down

Parker Millsap – Other Arrangements

Peter Rowan – Carter Stanley's Eyes

Pharis and Jason Romero – Sweet Old Religion

Phil Madeira – Providence

Pistol Annies – Interstate Gospel

Rosali – Trouble Anyway

Rosanne Cash – She Remembers Everything

Rosie & The Riveters – Ms. Behave

Ruby Boots – Don't Talk About It

Ruston Kelly – Dying Star

Ry Cooder – The Prodigal Son

Sam Lewis – Loversity

Sam Moss– Neon

Shemekia Copeland – America’s Child

Shooter Jennings – Shooter

Slocan Ramblers – Queen City Jubilee

St. Paul and the Broken Bones – Young Sick Camellia

The Beths – Future Me Hates Me

The Jayhawks – Back Roads and Abandoned Motels

The Mavericks – Hey! Merry Christmas

The Stray Birds – Let it Pass

The Wood Brothers – One Drop of Truth

Various Artists – Chicago Plays The Stones

We Banjo 3 – Haven

Whitey Morgan and the 78's – Hard Times and White Lines

Will Hoge – My American Dream

Yo La Tengo – There’s a Riot Going On

*      *      *      *      *       *

Your subscription helps keep independent roots music coverage alive! Subscribe to No Depression now and join a community of roots music fans from around the world.